What is a wife to do if this is her difficult situation where she is adamant, “I want to tithe!” And he is adamant, “I don’t want to tithe.”
NOTE – I am speaking about a hypothetical situation here. Greg and I wholeheartedly endorse tithing or even giving more than a tithe for believers in Christ. Not because we have to – but because we GET to!
Let’s do a little overview of the concept of tithing just to get our bearings biblically. (Don’t take my word for anything, please feel free to study the Bible yourself to confirm that what I am saying is correct.)
Tithing in the Old Testament:
Tithing was a requirement in the Old Testament Mosaic Law that provided money for God’s work and for His designated workers. The Levites were in charge of running the Temple and taking care of all of the sacrifices of the people. They had no land inheritance like the other 11 tribes did.
They were given land on which to live, but it did not belong to them. Their lives were to be fully devoted to service to the Lord. So the people’s tithes supported the tribe of Levi.
Also, Israel was a theocracy when it was established, so the Levites also fulfilled the function of a government. Everything that the entire nation needed for religious purposes and government purposes was accomplished through what God commanded the people to give in His law.
Tithing is not specifically required in the New Testament. We are no longer under the Mosaic Law. The church is not Israel. We do not support the Levites, the animal sacrificial system, or the Temple.
Jesus fulfilled all of the Old Testament Law and now, we are under Grace. So things are different in a lot of ways now because we are under the New Covenant rather than the Old Covenant.
However, giving is mentioned in the New Testament – giving money to the work of the Lord, sharing with those who teach and instruct us in the faith, and giving to the poor is also mentioned.
Tithing in the New Testament
Excerpt from www.gotquestions.org:
After the death of Jesus Christ fulfilled the Law, the New Testament nowhere commands, or even recommends, that Christians submit to a legalistic tithe system.
The New Testament nowhere designates a percentage of income a person should set aside, but only says gifts should be “in keeping with income” (1 Corinthians 16:2).
Some in the Christian church have taken the 10 percent figure from the Old Testament tithe and applied it as a “recommended minimum” for Christians in their giving.
The New Testament talks about the importance and benefits of giving. We are to give as we are able. Sometimes that means giving more than 10 percent; sometimes that may mean giving less.
There are believers in Christ who give 20% of their income to the Lord’s work to support local churches, mission work, and charities. And there are even those who give 90% and live off of 10%. I think that is amazing!
We are commanded to give as believers in Christ. It is not a command in the New Testament that we must give a specific percentage now. Rather, it is our joy, honor, and privilege to give generously and cheerfully out of thanksgiving for all that Jesus has done for us.
I wholeheartedly endorse giving to the Lord’s work! If you and your husband agree on 10%, that is awesome!
If you agree on some other amount, that is great! Giving, like just about everything else in the New Testament, is primarily a heart issue. The Lord blesses us in many ways as we give generously.
- “Give, and it will be given to you. A good measure, pressed down, shaken together and running over, will be poured into your lap. For with the measure you use, it will be measured to you.” Luke 6:38
If My Husband Doesn’t Want to Tithe
First, I think it is important to take special note of 2 Corinthians 9:7.
“Each man should decide in his heart to give, not reluctantly or under compulsion, for God loves a cheerful giver.”
If my husband doesn’t want to give as much as I do, I may consider giving “behind his back.” Or I might give with his knowledge, but knowing he is not in agreement.
Unfortunately, attitudes like these are disrespectful toward my husband’s God-given leadership in our home and toward his free-will.
They are also disrespectful toward the Lord. God is not going to bless my giving to His work if I am giving in a way that is dishonest or disrespectful to my husband or to God’s system of order.
My attitude is important. And my husband’s attitude is important, too. God wants us both to willingly and voluntarily choose to give what we give. Both of us must be on board.
I can absolutely respectfully share what I want to give or that I would like to tithe:
- Honey, I would really love to start tithing. What do you think?
- I’ve been thinking that it would be amazing if we might give X% or $X amount to the church and/or Christian ministries each month.
- It would mean so much to me if we could sponsor a child with a Christian charity.
In my understanding, the amount of money a Christian or Christian couple decides to give to the Lord and His work is a matter of personal conviction.
This means, I don’t get to accuse my husband of sinning if he doesn’t want to give 10% to church, if he calculates a tithe differently from how I would, or if he wants to give in a way that is different from my preference.
So if I want to tithe, but my husband isn’t on board, now what?
If I had a desire to tithe, but my husband did not, then I would want to let him just think about my respectful request and wait on God to work in his heart.
Or if we were on the same page about tithing, but if I wanted to ask about giving more than we have been giving, I could share what I want to do and then give him some time to think about things.
Some husbands are fine with the wife tithing her own money. Some husbands have particular charities they trust and prefer to support. Some have valid reasons why they don’t want to give to certain ministries.
There are all kinds of different arrangements that couples construct. The biggest thing is, I want to be sure to honor the Lord by respecting my husband’s decision and not run ahead. I don’t want to force him into giving against his will.
As I wait, I can pray:
You know my heart to want to give so much more financially to Your church and to Your work. Please inspire my husband to want to give generously, too. Help us to be cheerful givers.
I know he needs to make up his own mind and decide to give without me forcing or coercing him to. Help me to be patient and wait and to treat my husband with a godly, respectful, honoring attitude.
And help me to see ways I can contribute to Your kingdom and share Your love while I wait on You to work in his heart on this issue. I trust You to work. I am not going to run ahead and try to force my way. I thank You and praise You for what You will do in this area for Your glory!
If you would like for me to consider anonymously sharing your story related to the issue of tithing and giving and how the Lord worked in your own marriage, I’d love to hear about it! Please send an 800-1000 word story to my Contact Page.
Does a Christian Have to Tithe? – by The Billy Graham Evangelistic Association
Is My Husband Bound by My Personal Convictions?
My Husband Doesn’t Want Me to Minister Like I Want To
My Husband Isn’t Being a Good Enough Spiritual Leader
Posts about Various Ways Different Couples Handle Finances